Navigation Bar

Image Map

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Battle of the Chocolate Chip Cookies

When surfing Pintrest I always hesitant to believe the pin descriptions that claim being the best of something. Recently I came across a chocolate chip cookie recipe that claimed to be "the fluffiest, chewiest, most amazing chocolate chip cookies." I LOVE chocolate chip cookies, homemade that is. I know they are the most standard, and probably boring, cookies but that's why I love them. Rather than pinning the recipe because I was curious and then forgetting about it, I pinned it and immediately made my way to the kitchen and started up my KitchenAid. Inpsired by making one batch, I decided to prowl Pinterest for two more hot recipes. Time to determine which one is indeed the best! Here are the contenders:

Cookie A

Cookie B

Cookie C
The Claim
Cookie A: the fluffiest, chewiest, most amazing chocolate chip cookies
Cookie B: World's best chocolate chip cookies
Cookie C: Super soft chocolate chip cookies

Each recipe is slightly different. The biggest differences I found was that Cookie A called for cornstarch and Cookie B called for quite a bit more chocolate chips and only Cookie C called for both baking soda and baking powder (Cookies A and B used only baking soda). All recipes called for white and brown sugar as well as the other basics (butter, flour, salt, vanilla, chocolate chips).

In the end I felt like Cookie B and C tasted quite a like other than the fact that cookie B had way too many chocolate chips! Not a good chip to dough ratio. Both were soft but because they were doughy. I honestly didn't think they were anything special, could easily be the recipe off of a chocolate chip bag. Cookie A however was unlike any chocolate chip recipe I have ever made! It was indeed fluffy and it had a great salty sweet flavor! With each bit there was just a small hint of salt flavor which I actually liked a lot! I'm not sure I'd call them chewy but rather soft.


For now, Cookie A will be my go to chocolate chip cookie recipe! You can click on the contender pictures in order to visit the respectable websites to obtain the recipes! Happy baking!


No comments:

Post a Comment

I love reading your comments so please don't be shy! I'll usually even invite myself over after you've dropped a note to see what you're up to!

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...